Skip to main content
London Tutorsby KnowledgeDottCom

20 November 2026 · London Tutors

Nine Distances, No More: The Doughnut Puzzle Mathematicians Just Solved

Scatter dots around a doughnut by the same step, over and over — how many different distances can a dot be from its nearest neighbour? A new proof says never more than nine, settling a conjecture from 2021.

Nine Distances, No More: The Doughnut Puzzle Mathematicians Just Solved

Here is a puzzle you can try with a piece of string and a clock face. Pick a step — say, a quarter-turn plus a tiny bit — and keep walking around the clock by that same step, marking each place you land. After twenty steps, look at the gaps between neighbouring marks. However many steps you take, and whatever step size you chose, the gaps between neighbours will come in at most three different sizes. That beautiful fact is the three-distance theorem, also called the Steinhaus conjecture, proved in the 1950s.

Now take the same idea into three dimensions. Instead of a circle, walk around a doughnut shape — mathematicians call it a torus — stepping by the same amount in three directions at once. Each point now has a nearest neighbour, and the question becomes: how many different nearest-neighbour distances can appear? In 2021, Alan Haynes and Jens Marklof proved the answer in two dimensions is five, and guessed that in three dimensions it would be nine. They could only prove it was no more than thirteen.

That guess has now been settled. In a paper published in November 2026 in the International Mathematics Research Notices, mathematician Nikita Shulga proves that on a three-dimensional torus, at most nine distinct nearest-neighbour distances can ever occur — whatever the step, and however many points you place. Better still, the proof works in every dimension: on a d-dimensional torus the number is at most 2 to the power d, plus one. So in one dimension that gives three, in two dimensions five, and in three dimensions nine — matching the known results exactly.

And nine is not just an upper limit; it really happens. An example found by Carl Dettmann, using the step (27, 97, 514) divided by 1,334 and 58 points, produces all nine distances. So the theorem is sharp: nine is the true answer, not merely a safe estimate.

What makes this lovely for learners is how much deep mathematics hides inside a simple game. The proof leans on how well numbers can be approximated by fractions — a subject called Diophantine approximation — and on the geometry of lattices, the repeating grids that also describe crystals and honeycombs. A question that sounds like a playground puzzle turns out to need some of the most delicate tools in number theory.

If your child enjoys patterns, puzzles or the question "but how many can there be?", this is maths at its most playful — and it is exactly the kind of thinking that builds confidence with numbers, shapes and proof. You can find a maths tutor to explore puzzles like this with them, post a tutoring request to compare tutors, or browse maths workbooks in the bookshop for extra practice at home.

If your child loves a puzzle with a surprising answer, a first lesson in maths can start with dots on a doughnut and end with the number theory behind it — and you will find workbooks to keep the practice going here: Book your first lesson

Sources:

  • Shulga, N., "Nine-distance theorem and growth of best-approximation denominators", International Mathematics Research Notices, November 2026: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2608.01443v1
  • Haynes, A. and Marklof, J., "A five distance theorem for Kronecker sequences", arXiv:2009.08444 (2021): https://arxiv.org/abs/2009.08444

Curious about maths? Post a request on London Tutors and compare verified maths tutors — online, in person or in a group class.

Ready to find the right tutor?

Browse verified tutors, compare profiles, and book a trial lesson — free to sign up.

Find a tutor — sign up free

Related guides