Princeton Mathematicians Prove a Quantum Puzzle: No Sudden Meltdown in a Toy Black Hole
Two mathematicians at Princeton University have proved that a quantum model used to study black holes behaves in a remarkably orderly way. Arpon Basu and Siddhant Midha showed that the model's partition function obeys the famous Lee-Yang theorem — a result about where the zeroes of a mathematical function can lie, with big consequences for whether a system can suddenly change state. The work was posted to the arXiv preprint server on 2 November 2026 and has not yet been peer-reviewed.
What is a partition function?
In statistical mechanics — the physics of many particles at once — the partition function is a single mathematical object that encodes everything about a system at a given temperature: its energy, its entropy, and how it responds to change. If you know the partition function, you know the system.
Physicists study simplified models to understand complex materials. One famous example is the Sachdev–Ye–Kitaev (SYK) model, a collection of interacting quantum particles that acts as a toy model for holographic black holes. Working out its exact properties at every temperature has been hard, because the mathematics of all those interactions is so tangled.
The Lee-Yang idea, in plain English
In the 1950s, physicists Tsung-Dao Lee and Chen-Ning Yang discovered something beautiful: for certain systems, the zeroes of the partition function — the values where it equals zero — all lie on a single straight line, the imaginary axis. When that happens, the system is guaranteed not to undergo a sudden phase transition at any finite temperature. No abrupt freezing or melting; the system changes smoothly.
Basu and Midha studied a mathematical structure called a q-deformed oscillator, which acts as a stand-in for the SYK model in a particular scaling regime. By writing its partition function as a limit of polynomials whose roots are all real, they proved that all of its zeroes lie on the imaginary line — exactly the Lee-Yang property. This settles earlier predictions made from computer simulations, and gives exact limits on how close the zeroes can come to real temperatures.
Why it matters
The result reaches further than one oscillator. In the limit where the number of particles grows very large, the team showed the SYK model's partition function also takes on the Lee-Yang property. They also proved that the "quenched" version of the partition function — the one that accounts for the specific random disorder in the material — keeps a zero-free strip around the real axis with high probability.
That zero-free strip has a practical payoff. Following frameworks developed by mathematician Alexander Barvinok, the absence of zeroes near physical temperatures lets ordinary computers approximate thermodynamic properties, such as free energy, exponentially faster than the usual exact methods. The proof itself uses a striking mix of tools — Tutte polynomials and differential equations that make the roots repel each other, like electric charges pushing apart, so they cannot collide and drift off the imaginary axis.
Extending the techniques to weaker interaction strengths remains an open challenge, but the authors suggest their approach could become a general recipe for proving that other disordered quantum systems also avoid sudden phase transitions.
Why students should care
This is mathematics doing what it does best: finding hidden order inside chaos. A question about where the roots of a polynomial sit turns out to decide whether a model of a black hole can suddenly change state — and whether a computer can calculate its properties quickly. It is a reminder that the algebra students learn at school, from roots of equations to graphs, is the same toolkit that researchers use to probe black holes.
If your child is working towards GCSE or A-level maths and wants to build that kind of step-by-step confidence, a tutor can help — especially with the algebra, functions and proof techniques that sit behind stories like this one. Our bookshop also has GCSE maths revision workbooks for structured practice at home.
Find the right GCSE maths workbook for your child in our bookshop, or start with a tutor: Book your first lesson
Sources: Princeton Mathematicians Solve Quantum Physics Puzzle With Lee-Yang Proof, Bioscience; Basu and Midha, "Lee-Yang theorems for q-deformed oscillators and doubly-scaled SYK", arXiv, posted 2 November 2026
Curious about maths? Post a request on London Tutors and compare verified maths tutors — online, in person or in a group class.